Super Moist Carrot Sheet Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting (2024)

This Moist Carrot Sheet Cake has all the great spiced flavor of a traditional carrot cake in an easy to make sheet cake!

Carrot cake has a way of bringing out alllll the strong opinions. Should it have pineapple? Nuts or no nuts? What about raisins?

I have my own strong opinions, and this Carrot Sheet Cake meets all my requirements and then some. It’s super moist, subtly spiced, and topped with a dreamy cream cheese frosting. Give it a try, and you might just be convinced this is the best carrot cake recipe!

So, what makes this carrot sheet cake so special?

1. First things first–the carrots! Most carrot cakes call for two cups of shredded carrots, but this one includes three whole cups. More carrots gives this cake a more robust flavor and texture than other recipes.

2. Pineapple! That’s right, I love my carrot cake with pineapple! The pineapple compliments the flavor of the carrots well, and I love the subtle tangy zing it adds. Plus, it makes this carrot cake so incredibly tender and moist. What’s not to love about that?

3. Nuts. I personally love carrot cake with nuts. I like the extra texture a crunchy nut brings to the cake. Pecans are my favorite, but walnuts also work well here.

I realize many people are firmly against nuts in their dessert. My simple solution is to add chopped pecans to the top of the cake rather than bake them inside. This way, the nuts can be added to just half the cake, and everyone can be happy!

4. Finally, I’m on team NO RAISINS. I’m not a raisin hater in general. I love a good oatmeal raisin cookie, and a juicy raisin in a Morning Glory Muffin can be delightful.

But raisins in carrot cake? They’re just a distraction. I don’t want any unwelcome raisins interrupting my bite of moist, cinnamony carrot cake.

If you are on Team Raisins, feel free to add them. I always recommend soaking them in liquid before adding to the batter so they’re nice and juicy instead of dry. Water, orange juice, or pineapple juice all work great for this!

What Frosting Goes with Carrot Sheet Cake?

For this question, I don’t think there’s much debate. Cream cheese frosting is the absolute best frosting for carrot cake. The slight tang of cream cheese frosting compliments this spiced carrot cake perfectly.

I like my cream cheese frosting to be heavy on the cream cheese and not overly sweet. This recipe calls for two sticks of cream cheese and only one stick of butter, so the cream cheese flavor really shines!

Make sure your cream cheese and butter are at room temperature and sift your powdered sugar to ensure an extra creamy, smooth cream cheese frosting.

Why I Love Making Carrot Sheet Cake

Layer carrot cakes are obviously gorgeous and perfect for special occasions, but I really love the simplicity of a great carrot sheet cake.

Sheet cakes are so easy to make. They don’t involve any stacking or torting, and frosting them takes about 2 minutes, tops. Sheet cakes are great for feeding a crowd, and for bringing to potlucks and casual gatherings. My Zucchini Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting and Chocolate Crazy Cake are regulars in our rotation.

I make my sheet cakes in a 9 x 13 inch pan rather than a half sheet pan, because I prefer thicker slices of cake. Feel free to use a bigger pan, but be sure to reduce the baking time.

Storage and Make Ahead Instructions

How do you store carrot cake?

This Carrot Sheet Cake can be stored, covered, in the fridge for up to a week.

Some people love carrot cake eaten straight from the fridge (my husband). I prefer it warmed up in the microwave until the cream cheese frosting is just starting to melt a bit. How you serve it is up to you!

Can I bake carrot cake ahead of time?

This Carrot Sheet Cake keeps very well in the fridge. In fact, I actually think it gets better the second and third days!

If you’d like to make it very far in advance, you can freeze carrot cake by double wrapping the unfrosted cake tightly in saran wrap and then foil and storing it in the freezer. You can thaw the cake in the fridge overnight then frost as usual!

FAQs

Can you make carrot cake cupcakes with this recipe?

Yes! This recipe will make about two dozen cupcakes. Bake time will be 20-25 minutes.

Can you bake this in a different size pan?

Yes! This recipe can be made in 2 8 or 9 inch square or round pans, a 9 x 13 inch pan, or a half sheet pan. Note that the slices will be much thinner in the sheet pan. Almost like bars!

The baking times will be different if you change the pan. Here’s a great cake baking times guide for different pans.

Can you stack this carrot cake recipe?

I would not recommend stacking this recipe as written. The cake is already quite thick and dense and would be overwhelming if stacked.

If you would like to stack it, I would recommend making thinner cakes in several round pans or a half sheet cake. Please note that the cream cheese frosting we use is not good for piping. It is a soft, smooth, and extra creamy cream cheese frosting!

What to Serve with Carrot Sheet Cake

This cake is really lovely for any occasion, but it’s often served at Easter and other spring events. You can check out our full Easter brunch menu here.

Some of our favorite recipes to serve with carrot cake include Green Pea Soup with Candied Bacon, Sweet Orange Glazed Ham, Easy Cheesy Potatoes, Make Ahead Butterhorn Rolls, and Honey Roasted Parsnips and Carrots.